Vino Fino 2017 Holiday Wine & Food Marathon
Notes and photos by
The 2017 Vino Fino Holiday event was bittersweet, marked by
remembrances of members whom we lost this past year.
Pat Donahue passed away after a battle with some
severely debilitating disease...
Dave Greiner passed away in July of this year.
We decanted the various bottles of wine brought by Vino Fino members to pair
with the dinner at San Francisco's Olympic Club.
These bottles are "double decanted," first from the
bottle into a decanter and then, once the bottle has been rinsed and cleaned of
its sediment, back into the original bottle.
Though we try to be neat about this, inevitably, there's a
mess of a battlefield.
We had all the bottles double-decanted and were ready for the
games to begin.
We had a couple of magnums of Champagne to accompany the seafood starters...
To begin, we opened the Pierre Moncuit Grand Cru Brut...
This is made entirely of Chardonnay grown in Les Mesnil, a grand cru site in the
It's quite dry and bracingly crisp...perfect with the Oysters and Prawns.
Stacey Donahue joined us this holiday event...
The dapper John McGlothlin said a few words about our late
Vino Fino prankster John Vignau.
Tim Zainer and Mark Naismith
Ernie Andersen and Allan Andersen
Mike Fehr, Larry Lanctot and Jack Sweitzer
Stacey shared some "Pat stories" and thanked everyone for inviting her
participate in the festivities.
Mark Naismith gave an impassioned speech about the Vino Fino members whom we
lost this year (and earlier).
The second magnum of bubbles was then uncorked and this Cuvée Fleuron by Pierre
Gimonnet was delicious, too. It's entirely Chardonnay and mostly from
Grand Cru sites with a modest fraction coming from the Premier Cru village of
Cuis (with grand cru wines from Chouilly, Cramant and Oger accounting for 81.5%
of the blend).
It's undergone a malolactic fermentation and the wine is quite dry and a bit
fuller in body and somewhat more profound than the Moncuit.
With that, people dug in to the little seafood buffet.
We poured some "Memorial" bottles to toast the former members of our
John McGlothlin brought a 2006 Stony Hill Chardonnay in honor of John Vignau.
The nose of the wine was quite good...lots of fruit and a mildly appley
character. Notes of pear and ripe melon, too. Dry...medium bodied...not
"Burgundian," but quite nice.
Stacey brought a Château Poujeaux from the 1996 vintage, a little Bordeaux Pat
had stored in the cellar. It displayed some tobacco notes and character
consistent with it being a 20+ year old Cabernet-based red from the Medoc.
There was even a touch of tannin remaining.
Ernie Anderson offered a "David Greiner Memorial Bottle." This
was a 2000 vintage of Château Pavie, a Saint Emilion of note.
This was a monster! Never mind that it's 17+ years of age, this is a baby!
Inky black in color, it's very concentrated and intense...lots of black fruit
notes...nicely oaked, too. Very showy, if a bit unusual in its intensity.
To begin we had a Seared Sea Scallop...
The Guigal "La Doriane" Condrieu was quite good, but having been in
the ice a bit too long, this took a while to warm and blossom...but when it did
this was outstanding. Lots of peachy notes and some sweet, toasty,
vanillin oak...very complex.
The Quail dish was next...
A 2012 Kosta Browne Pinot Noir from the Koplen vineyard...beautiful sweet fruit
notes and sweet oak...
We read recently that Kosta Browne was going to change its style and make less
"opulent" Pinot Noirs...
Tasting this bottle, we're not sure they need to change...
We then embarked on a Cabernet journey, beginning with A 1990 Château Les Ormes
This is an easy and simple Bordeaux...fully evolved and quite at its peak.
A 2008 vintage of Silver Oak's Alexander Valley Cabernet came next...classic
Silver Oak...lots of woodsy notes from the American oak barrels...young and
We had two vintages of Opus One...1992 came first.
It began with a mildly herbal note...fairly smooth and then it veered off into a
slightly horsy character coming through on the palate.
The 1991 Opus was brighter and more elegant. Classic.
A 2004 Phelps Insignia was very fine...woodsy, dark fruit...some sweet tones and
it had some depth and length.
Still young, but developing handsomely...it has some life to it, so it can
probably go another 10+ years, well-stored.
The 1995 Château Lynch Bages was showing well, a bottle from the cellar of the
late Pat Donahue.
Nicely developed nose with good bottle bouquet, there's a mild cassis note to
its fragrance and on the palate. Medium bodied and with light
The 1978 Château LaGrange was a good example of "old" Bordeaux...some
tobacco notes dominated the nose and palate...medium-bodied, elegant and more
than ready-to-drink, but still in good condition.
We enjoyed two dessert wines...the first was a 1999 Château Suduiraut...a
nicely mature Sauternes with loads of honey notes. It's sweet, to be sure,
but has ample acidity to keep the wine balanced.
A Bûche de Noël was exceptional.
Accompanying the dessert was Penfolds Grandfather Tawny
Reserve...they used to call it "Port," but these days the label has
It's said the solera from which this comes averages about 20 years of age.
It's a delicious dessert wine and paired perfectly with the chocolaty decadence
we enjoyed as dessert.
"Drink up all y'all."
And having nearly emptied all the glasses, we packed up and
trundled out on to the street to take BART back home.
[file:///C:/Documents and Settings/Gerald/Desktop/Weimax_Web-2007/Tasting Archive Rosters/weimax_tasting_archive1.htm]
Happy Holidays everyone!